Dreikurs also established the first adlerian child guidance center in the united states and trained counselors from many countries, who subsequently established adleriandreikursian family centers in many parts of the world. Kohn goes on to describe a situation dreikurs wrote about in his logical consequences. Rudolf dreikurs 18971972 austrian born american psychiatrist and educator alfred adler community child guidance center of chicago. Dreikurs also believed that all students desire to feel they have value and to feel they can contribute to templates the classroom. A consequence is a result of something a person does. Logical consequences is not nearly as well written as children. The positive discipline association is a program that teaches young people to be responsible, respectful and resourceful members of their communities positive discipline association. Logical consequences using logical consequences should result in rapid changes in the childs behavior within the targeted routine or activity if using logical consequences is not successful, think about why the child is engaging in the challenging behavior and. Instead of imposing logical consequences, involve children in thinking of solutions. Their theory and practice of seeing maladaptive behaviour in. Logical consequences quotes from children the challenge by rudolf dreikurs when we use the term logical consequences, parents so frequently misinterpret it as a new way to impose their demands upon children. It is important to decide what kind of consequence would create a helpful learning experience that might encourage children to choose responsible cooperation.
Dreikurs model of social discipline in classrooms video. Dreikurs logical consequences motivation selfimprovement. Letting children experience the natural or logical consequences of their actions is one way to teach. Dreikurs ideas using logical consequences is the most helpful idea to come along in years. Systematic training for effective parenting 3rd ed. The dreikurs theory for classroom management, sometimes called rudolf dreikurs theory of social discipline, acts as a framework for thinking. The second half of the book, however, reads more like a reference sourcegoing from vignette to vignette in quick procession. Classroom management theorists and theoriesrudolf dreikurs. Misbehavior can be prevented by paying attention to individual students needs essential elements. Your child is likely to not fight bringing a jacket the next time if he was shivering, for instance.
Rudolf dreikurs, who was a student of adler, built on this philosophy and tailored it toward students. Dreikurs impact on childrearing practices and his contribution to individual psychology was recently. When frustrated in their attempts to gain the recognition they desire, their behavior turns toward four mistaken goals. I read this as a newish mother, with just one 2 or 3 yearold, and a baby. A 2nd grade male student who talked out of turn, squirmed a lot, and so on was given the logical consequence of being taken from the classroom and told to. Logical consequences should not be used if the child does not understand the options and is not able to make a decision about the action to choose. If used appropriately, logical consequences should result in rapid. Hardin ch5 lecture logical consequences dreikurs youtube. When developed, logical consequences represented a shift from behavioral focus on discipline to more humanistic approach, using the concept that motivation and goals of student behavior must be. Quotes from children the challenge by rudolf dreikurs. Logical consequences dreikurs classroom management. Doctoral student, school of criminology simon fraser university burnaby, bc email. The term logical consequences was suggested by dreikurs in 1946 1 to clarify some confusions which were apparent in understanding the earlier concept. Basic assumptions inappropriate behaviour is motivated by the need to gain attention when the motive of gaining attention is satisfied, it manifested inappropriate behaviour associated with other motives by helping students find other ways to satisfy their needs, inappropriate behaviour can be.
Dreikurs logical consequences free download as powerpoint presentation. Dreikurs was often credited with elaborating, building, and working out in a clear, systematic and logical form, the basic ideas of individual psychology. A response to the punishment debate within restorative justice by colleen pawlychka, b. Alternatives to logical consequences positive discipline. Logical consequences are respectful of the childs dignity while punishment often calls upon an element of shame. I think when we say we are using logical consequences to teach our kids we are fooling ourselves. Semantic scholar extracted view of logical consequences. We can use consequences as preventative safety measures but i disagree that they are teaching tools. Often, allowing the natural consequence to occur will prevent a parentchild argument and the child will learn the right lesson. Logical consequences involve action taken by the parent. Logical consequences are different from natural consequences in that they require the intervention of an adultor other children in a family or a class meeting. This is the basis of democracy, since it implies equality of individuals.
Page 2 logical consequences by rudolf dreikurs logical consequences shift from a behavioral focus on discipline more humanistic approachusing motivation and goals of students behavior. Community child guidance centers of chicago golden rule. Most misbehavior results from their attempts to get it. The development of logical consequences, adequately. Rudolf dreikurs the social discipline mellisa ostrega model mike blanco nessa rodriguez. This philosophy is based on helping a person to determine their personal goals in order to resolve their own issues in life. It is a powerful way of responding to childrens misbehavior that not only is effective in stopping the behavior but is respectful of children and helps them to. Logical consequences dreikurs models of discipline. Logical consequences respond to the misbehavior in ways that preserve the dignity of the child. Logical consequences are most useful when a childs action could result in harm to the child.
However, logical consequences are rarely necessary and are only one possibility. The use of logical consequences logical consequences are not used to threaten or intimidate a child. I only wish i had learned this when my own children were young. H page start 93 page end 121 is part of book title classroom discipline and management authors clifford h. Rudolph dreikurs taught that logical consequences are effective only for the mistaken goal of undue attention and are only one option even for that goal. Dreikurs 1968 developed the logical consequences model, built on the belief that we learn through our interactions with the. Using natural and logical consequences umn extension. Includes an extended appendix addressing narcissistic behaviours. A short introduction dr bill rogers 2017 au draft only 2017. These ideas have been around for many decades but outside pressures and criticisms caused them to be discounted. In adulthood, we have logical consequences mandated by law. Edwards date 2000 publisher wiley pub place new york edition 3rd isbn10 0476522x isbn 97804765228. Thirdly, dreikurs emphasized the importance of avoiding power struggles with students. Kari clark and kylee hoiland democratic teaching dreikurs defines democratic teaching by helping students reach their genuine goal of belonging by involving students in decisions that affect their school lives.
Dreikurs et al 1982 postulates that teachers should ask a few key questions to. The use of logical consequences in interpersonal relations loren grey, ph. This book helped me put a lot of things in perspective parentingwise, helped me know that i wasnt the first to go through the struggles of having a willful child, and helped me figure out how to discipline with greater thought and less kneejerk reaction. Punishment or logical consequences antonio casella. Alfred adler developed the theory called individual psychology. And a child who loses access to his cell phone for texting too much is likely to remember not to do that again. Rudolf dreikurs theory is based on the notion that everyone wants to fit in. A key tenet of logical consequences is that children should be given a choice rather than forced to behave as directed. But these consequences are to keep the child safe not to teach a lesson.
A new approach to discipline by rudolf dreikurs et al. In reference to dreikurs view of logical consequences, spanking thsory seem a bit absurd. Do unto others as you would have others do unto you. Natural and logical consequences result from choices children make about their behavior. Tc, combining profound insights with practical bits of information, as did c. Dreikurs model logical consequences linkedin slideshare. Rudolf dreikurs logical consequences by brittany kessler.
Logical consequences by dreikurs, rudolf and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Since the late 1960s and i 970s, many teachers, like sara prabhu, have adopted dreikurs s model, logical consequences. Rudolf dreikurs inspiring classroom behavior strategies by. Chapter 5 logical consequences logical consequences is a method of classroom management that was developed by rudolf dreikurs. If used appropriately, logical consequences should result in. Classroom management strategies to take control of noisy students. The message is that the behavior is a problem, not that the child is a problem. It is important to make sure that logical consequences are reasonable and related to the problem, and to let both the child and the parent keep their selfrespect.
The children see this for what it is disguised punishment. Hardin ch5 lecture logical consequences dreikurs joe jerles. Logical consequences dreikurs free download as powerpoint presentation. Logical consequences orderly purposeful directed toward seeking social approval some students may misbehave for reasons other than the desire to belong i. The work of alfred adler and rudolf dreikurs in reference to behaviour in and counselling of students attentional and powerseeking behaviour. Dreikurs logical consequences free download as pdf file. Dreikurs model of social discipline is a method for addressing behavior issues that takes a strong stance on this issue. I have drawn primarily on the work of alfred adler and rudolf dreikurs. Dreikurs logical consequences mindmeister mind map. Dreikurs logical consequences classroom management motivation.
Chapter 5 logical consequences thursday, march 5, 2015. Punishment even when a poorly disguised as a consequence is designed to make kids. Both natural and logical consequences can help teach kids to make better choices and learn from their mistakes. These two examples illustrate the application of the logical consequences model and how children may be expected to respond. No more logical consequences at least hardly ever focus. Teachers must recognize and deal effectively with these. Logical consequences dreikurs the dreikurs model of confronting mistaken goals. Logical consequences, as we learned in the last two articles, are ways in which adults structure learning opportunities for children. The first part of the book is written up to par of c. While most agree that his greatest contribution was in the application and practice of individual psychology, some felt he.
165 68 1168 117 749 267 1481 189 1011 1136 545 1495 521 382 1464 1594 473 597 514 936 782 1018 1583 546 1222 86 1289 577 666 737 1262 881 140 832 907 1485 932 696 1193 271